Hill Street Dog Park Community Coalition logo
← hillstreetdogpark.ca
Vote results

The final, counted results of the community vote.

Voting closed

Community vote on the small-dog area: final results

Voting opened September 14, 2026 and closed September 27, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. Eastern Time. Below are every option's final count, in order, followed by the baseline option that was removed before voting ended, how the vote was counted, and what happens next.

70
Ballots cast
Sept 14
Voting opened, 2026
Sept 27
Voting closed, 2026
The three most-supported alternatives going to the City: C, B and D.
1
Option C

Move it to the east end

WaterHill St.West gateEast gategate to the waterdouble gate outfence removed, panels reusedMain area

The current fence comes out and the panels are reused across the east end, beside the water and the children's park. The main area becomes one uninterrupted run, end to end.

Small-dog area
≈17% of the park
Main area
≈83% of the park
Credited to
Romy
70 points · 100.0% of ballots cast · 38 ballots backing it (54%)
2
Option B

The path becomes the fence line

WaterHill St.West gateEast gatewest gate rebuilt out–in–out:the small-dog way in and outgate into the main areanorth half of the fence keptsouth half removedMain area

The fence follows the existing path from the west gate east to the fence line where it stands today. The south half of the current fence comes out, so the small-dog area becomes the strip along the tree line and the open south strip goes back to the main park. The west gate is rebuilt as a triple out–in–out, serving as the small-dog area’s own way in and out, and a gate in the kept section opens into the main area.

Small-dog area
≈24% of the park
Main area
≈76% of the park
Credited to
Alto, Vivi and Robert
41 points · 58.6% of ballots cast · 26 ballots backing it (37%)
3
Option D

Gates only, no fence change

WaterHill St.West gateEast gateLocked gatetwo sets of double gates, no cross-overMain area

Nothing moves. Two sets of double gates go in along the south fence, one for each area, with no crossing between them.

Small-dog area
≈30% of the park (City’s as-built drawing)
Main area
≈70% of the park
Credited to
Alto and Linda
30 points · 42.9% of ballots cast · 15 ballots backing it (21%)
4
Option F

A wide gate anyone can open

WaterHill St.West gateEast gateextra-wide gate, anyone can open itsign asks people to close it whensmall dogs are using that sideMain area

Nothing is rebuilt and nothing moves. The locked gate in the dividing fence is replaced with an extra-wide gate that any visitor can open, so when no small dogs are using the small-dog area the two sides become one open run. A sign at the gate asks people to close it again when small dogs are using that side.

Small-dog area
≈30% when the gate is closed (City’s as-built drawing)
Main area
≈70%, or the whole park when it is open
Credited to
Linda
20 points · 28.6% of ballots cast · 12 ballots backing it (17%)
5
Option G

Match the City’s original drawing + exchange gate

WaterHill St.West gateEast gateexchange gatefence todayMain area

Move the dividing fence to exactly match the position shown on the City’s own reference drawing, rather than where it was actually built. Add a new exchange gate where the fence crosses, so dogs and owners can pass between the main and small-dog areas. Under this drawing’s split, the calculated main-to-small density ratio (≈2.5×) is lower than the ≈2.9× estimated under the City’s September 17 as-built assumption used elsewhere on this site (see the report).

Small-dog area
0.26 of 1.06 acres, ≈24.5% (per City drawing)
Main area
0.80 of 1.06 acres, ≈75.5%
Credited to
Robert
18.5 points · 26.4% of ballots cast · 12 ballots backing it (17%)
6
Option A

Shrink it where it is

WaterHill St.West gateEast gategate through the fencefence todayMain area

The dividing fence is rebuilt further west, with a gate through it. The small-dog area keeps its position and its shade, and the main area takes the rest.

Small-dog area
≈14% of the park
Main area
≈86% of the park
Credited to
Niall and Bryan
18 points · 25.7% of ballots cast · 13 ballots backing it (19%)
7
Option E

Change the rule, not the fence

WaterHill St.West gateEast gateLocked gateCalm sideActive sidenew signs, nothing built

Nothing is built. The two sides are redefined by what a dog needs rather than its size — a calm side for older, anxious or recovering dogs of any size, and an active side.

Small-dog area
≈30% of the park (City’s as-built drawing)
Main area
≈70% of the park
Credited to
Lee
12.5 points · 17.9% of ballots cast · 9 ballots backing it (13%)
Not on the final ballot

“Keep it as it is”

This choice was added to the ballot as a comparison baseline but was not one of the solutions the community submitted. It was on the ballot from September 14–24, 2026, before being removed, and its votes are not included in the results above.

While it was on the ballot: 89.5 points on 35 of 79 ballots cast at that time (113.3% share).

How the vote was counted

One vote per person, enforced by a verified email address: each ballot was checked against a one-way hash of the voter's email so the same person couldn't vote twice. No email addresses were stored. Voters could back up to three options; each ballot carried a fixed 3-point budget split evenly across its picks (one pick = 3 points, two picks = 1.5 points each, three picks = 1 point each). Share is each option's points as a percentage of ballots cast; because a ballot can back more than one option, shares add up to more than 100%.